Issues with Matthew
Devised Literary Structure of Matthew
Overview: Matthew’s Schematic Literary Design
Unlike ancient historiography that follows a broadly chronological sequence of journeys and public events, the Gospel of Matthew is organized around an artificial, catechetical architecture: alternating blocks of narrative action and massive topical discourses, framed by an infancy prologue and a passion-resurrection epilogue and subdivided throughout by mnemonic triads, pentads, and heptads. Across twentieth- and twenty-first-century scholarship, commentators have recognized that this devised literary structure derives not from eyewitness memory of Jesus’ itinerary, but from the deliberate scribal and liturgical craft of the First Evangelist.
The Fivefold “New Pentateuch” Structure
Benjamin Wisner Bacon, Studies in Matthew (1930)
The classic demonstration that Matthew organized chapters 3–25 into five composite “books” modeled on the five books of the Mosaic Torah—each pairing an introductory narrative section with a major teaching discourse sealed by a stereotypic transitional formula (Matt 7:28; 11:1; 13:53; 19:1; 26:1), and bracketed by a Preamble (Matt 1–2) and an Epilogue (Matt 26–28)—was set forth by Benjamin Wisner Bacon in Studies in Matthew (New York: Henry Holt and Company, 1930; public domain), pp. xiv–xvii (building on Sir John C. Hawkins, Horae Synopticae, 2nd ed. [Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1909], pp. 163–167):
“A half-century ago it was recognized that its compiler has followed the plan of aggregating his teaching material from all sources into five great discourses corresponding to the oration codes of the Pentateuch, each introduced, like the Mosaic codes, by a narrative section, each closing with a transition formula as the reader passes from discourse to narrative. To these five bodies of discourse Sir John Hawkins would apply the Hebrew term pereq, meaning ‘chapter’ or ‘section.’ The lay reader will find it easier to think of them as ‘Sermons’ in view of the first of the series, a discourse on the Righteousness of Sons, to which custom has applied the title ‘Sermon on the Mount.’ Prefixed to the first narrative section we find two loosely connected chapters relating the birth and infancy of Jesus from sources elsewhere unknown. This section, Matt 1–2, may most conveniently be designated the Preamble. Correspondingly after the last of the five discourses the transition formula leads over to three chapters (Matt 26–28) of closing narrative relating the passion and resurrection. This envoi we may call the Epilogue.” (Bacon, Studies in Matthew, pp. xiv–xv)
Bacon mapped this seven-part architecture across the twenty-eight chapters of Matthew as follows (Bacon 1930, p. xvii):
- Preamble: Chapters 1–2 (Genealogy and Infancy Narratives)
- Book I: Narrative A (chs. 3–4) introducing Discourse B (chs. 5–7, Sermon on the Mount; closed at Matt 7:28)
- Book II: Narrative A (chs. 8–9, Miracle Collection) introducing Discourse B (ch. 10, Mission Discourse; closed at Matt 11:1)
- Book III: Narrative A (chs. 11–12, Controversy and Rejection) introducing Discourse B (ch. 13, Kingdom Parables; closed at Matt 13:53)
- Book IV: Narrative A (chs. 14–17) introducing Discourse B (ch. 18, Church Community Discourse; closed at Matt 19:1)
- Book V: Narrative A (chs. 19–22) introducing Discourse B (chs. 23–25, Woes and Eschatological Discourse; closed at Matt 26:1)
- Epilogue: Chapters 26–28 (Passion and Resurrection Narratives)
G. D. Kilpatrick, The Origins of the Gospel According to St. Matthew (1946)
In The Origins of the Gospel According to St. Matthew (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1946; repr. Wauconda, IL: Bolchazy-Carducci Publishers, 2007), pp. 135–136, Oxford textual critic G. D. Kilpatrick contrasted Mark’s loose, episodic Galilean narrative between Mark 1:15 and Mark 10 with Matthew’s systematic reorganization of Mark 1–13 into the five structured books of Matthew 3–25 (Book 1: chs. 3–4 + 5–7; Book 2: chs. 8–9 + 10:1–11:1; Book 3: chs. 11–12 + 13:1–52; Book 4: 13:53–17:21 + 17:22–19:1; Book 5: 19:2–22:46 + chs. 23–25). Emphasizing that this Pentateuchal arrangement reflects individual scribal authorship rather than anonymous folk tradition, Kilpatrick concluded:
“This division is clearly modeled on the book of the Law and implies a contrast between Jesus and the Law which indicates both the Jewish background of the book and its Christological point of view. But this arrangement could only come from the author of the book, since it is not in the tradition, and circumstances and communities do not create books of themselves.” (Kilpatrick 1946, p. 136)
Chiastic and Concentric Proposals
In The Gospel of Matthew, Interpreting Biblical Texts (Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1997), pp. 25–27, Donald Senior notes how subsequent literary critics built upon Bacon’s five-discourse observation by proposing overarching chiastic (concentric ring, a–b–c–b'–a') designs intended to aid oral memory and public liturgical reading:
- Peter F. Ellis (Matthew: His Mind and His Message [Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 1974]) identified the Parable Discourse of chapter 13—where Jesus turns from mounting public opposition to instruct his disciples in the mysteries of the kingdom—as the structural fulcrum of an eleven-part symmetry:
aNarrative: Chapters 1–4 ↔a'Narrative: Chapters 26–28bSermon on the Mount: Chapters 5–7 ↔b'Woes and Judgment Discourse: Chapters 23–25cMiracle Narrative: Chapters 8–9 ↔c'Judean/Jerusalem Narrative: Chapters 19–22dMission Discourse: Chapter 10 ↔d'Community Discourse: Chapter 18eNarrative of Doubt and Conflict: Chapters 11–12 ↔e'Narrative of Discipleship: Chapters 14–17f[Center] Parables of the Kingdom: Chapter 13
- H. Benedict Green (The Gospel According to Matthew, New Clarendon Bible [Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1975]) proposed an alternative eleven-unit chiasm centered on chapter 11—where Jesus’ testimony regarding John the Baptist, the summary of messianic works, and Jesus’ revelation as the Son of the Father (Matt 11:25–30) mark the pivot between Jesus’ manifestation to Israel (chs. 1–10) and Israel’s progressive rejection culminating in the Passion (chs. 12–28; summarized in Senior 1997, pp. 26–27).
Scriptural Fulfillment Formulae and Moses Typology
Alongside discourse blocks and concentric symmetry, Senior (1997, pp. 33–34) highlights two further compositional devices through which Matthew scripts his narrative around the Hebrew Bible. First, Matthew punctuates key narrative transitions with explicit “fulfillment quotations”—five clustered in the infancy narrative alone (Matt 1:22–23 citing Isa 7:14; Matt 2:5–6 citing Mic 5:2; Matt 2:15 citing Hos 11:1; Matt 2:17–18 citing Jer 31:15; and Matt 2:23 appealing to “the prophets”), followed by strategic placements at the start of the Galilean ministry (Matt 4:14–16), miracle summaries (Matt 8:17; 12:17–21), parabolic teaching (Matt 13:14–15, 35), the entry into Jerusalem (Matt 21:4–5), Gethsemane (Matt 26:54, 56), and Judas’s death (Matt 27:9–10).
Second, Matthew clothes his narrative figures in deliberate Old Testament typology—above all portraying Jesus as the New Moses: just as Pharaoh slaughtered Hebrew male infants in Egypt while Moses was rescued, King Herod slaughters Bethlehem’s infants while a new Joseph leads Jesus into refuge in Egypt (Matt 2:13–21), before Jesus ascends a Sinai-like mountain (Matt 5:1–2) to promulgate the authoritative Torah of the kingdom (Senior 1997, p. 34; see also Dale C. Allison Jr., The New Moses: A Matthean Typology [Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 1993]).
Mnemonic and Numerical Groupings (Triads, Pentads, Heptads)
In An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1911; public domain), pp. 259–260, James Moffatt cataloged the extraordinary density of artificial numerical groupings—threes, fives, sevens, and tens—that pervade canonical Matthew as catechetical aids for oral memorization:
“Writing for the practical needs of the church, the author betrays the vocation of a teacher incidentally in the mnemonic and mathematical arrangements of his material, among other things... The irregular number of the beatitudes (Matt 5:3–12), where schematism would have been easy, shows that the writer did not work out numerical schemes quite regardless of the materials at his disposal, though homiletic influences undoubtedly were responsible for the form as occasionally for the content of the latter.” (Moffatt, An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament, pp. 259–260)
Groupings of Three (adapted from Moffatt 1911, pp. 259–260)
- Three fourteen-generation divisions in the royal genealogy (Matt 1:2–17)
- Three angelic dream-messages to Joseph in the infancy story (Matt 1:20; 2:13; 2:19; plus the Magi’s dream in 2:12 and Joseph’s warning in 2:22)
- Three temptations in the wilderness (Matt 4:1–11)
- Triple summary of Jesus’ Galilean ministry: teaching, proclaiming, healing (Matt 4:23; repeated in Matt 9:35)
- Triple escalating illustrations in the Sermon on the Mount (Matt 5:22; cf. 5:34–35; 5:39–41)
- Three pillars of Jewish piety—almsgiving, prayer, and fasting (Matt 6:1–4, 5–15, 16–18; cf. triple rhythms in 6:9–10; 7:7–8, 22, 25, 27)
- Three triads of miracle stories across chapters 8–9: three healings (Matt 8:1–15), three power/authority miracles (Matt 8:23–9:8), and three further restoration miracles (Matt 9:18–34)
- Triple rhythmic questions concerning John the Baptist (Matt 11:7–9; cf. 12:50)
- Threefold Pharisaic attack in chapter 12 (Matt 12:2, 10, 24)
- Three seed/growth parables (Matt 13:1–32)
- Three solemn “Truly, I say to you” pronouncements in the community discourse (Matt 18:3, 13, 18)
- Three classes of eunuchs (Matt 19:12)
- Threefold Passion prediction and acclamation rhythms (Matt 20:19; 21:9)
- Three polemical parables in the temple—Two Sons, Wicked Tenants, and Wedding Feast (Matt 21:28–22:14)
- Three test questions posed to Jesus in Jerusalem (Matt 22:15–40)
- Triadic warnings, herbs, virtues, and emissaries in chapter 23: three titles forbidden (Matt 23:8–10; cf. 23:20–22), three herbs vs. three weightier matters (“mint and dill and cumin” vs. “justice and mercy and faithfulness,” Matt 23:23), and “prophets and wise men and scribes” (Matt 23:34)
- Three servants entrusted with talents (Matt 25:14–30)
- Three prayers of Jesus in Gethsemane (Matt 26:36–45) and three denials by Peter (Matt 26:69–75)
- Three questions of Pilate (Matt 27:17–23), three mockeries at the cross (Matt 27:39–44), and three named/designated women at Golgotha (Matt 27:56)
- The threefold baptismal formula at the close of the Gospel (Matt 28:19)
Groupings of Five, Seven, Ten, and Fourteen (adapted from Moffatt 1911, p. 260)
- Fivefold structures: Five occurrences of the discourse-closing formula “When Jesus had finished these sayings” (καὶ ἐγένετο ὅτε ἐτέλεσεν ὁ Ἰησοῦς τοὺς λόγους τούτους, Matt 7:28; 11:1; 13:53; 19:1; 26:1); five/six antitheses in Matt 5:21–48; fivefold missionary charge in Matt 10:7–8 (cf. 10:9–10); and five wise vs. five foolish virgins in Matt 25:1–13.
- Sevenfold structures: Seven petitions in the Matthean Lord’s Prayer (Matt 6:9–13, expanded from five in Luke 11:2–4); seven parables in chapter 13; seven evil spirits (Matt 12:45); seventy-sevenfold forgiveness (Matt 18:21–22; cf. seven brothers in Matt 22:25); seven loaves and seven baskets (Matt 15:34, 37); and seven woes against the scribes and Pharisees in chapter 23 (expanded from six woes in Luke 11:42–52).
- Tenfold and fourteenfold structures: Ten Old Testament citations prior to the Galilean ministry (Matt 1:1–4:11); ten miracle accounts grouped across chapters 8–9 (Matt 8:1–9:34); and three sets of fourteen generations—matching the Hebrew gematria of David’s name (דוד = 4 + 6 + 4 = 14)—in Matthew 1:17.
